Stern's Bakery Black and White Cookies - 9-Count Individually Wrapped Gift Box, Kosher & Nut-Free

These are classic New York–style black and white cookies: soft cake-like rounds iced half-chocolate, half-vanilla, sold in a 9-count, individually wrapped kosher and nut-free gift box from Stern’s Bakery.

Enjoy a nostalgic bakery treat crafted to mirror the flavors and look legendary in NYC delis. Stern’s Bakery bakes each cookie to a roughly 3-inch diameter, wraps them individually for delivery freshness, and packages nine per gift box so you can share, stash, or gift with confidence. Certified kosher and produced in a nut-free facility, these cookies are made for celebrations, mail-order gift giving, or everyday indulgence.

How are these black and white cookies made to taste like the classic New York version?

They are baked with a tender, cake-like crumb and finished with a glossy half-vanilla, half-chocolate icing that creates the signature visual and flavor contrast. The balance of sweet icing and soft interior aims to recreate the familiar bite found in neighborhood bakeries.

• Approximately 3-inch diameter cookie, soft-centered texture.
• Two-part icing: vanilla on one side, chocolate on the other for contrast.
• Small-batch, bakery-style shaping and baking for authentic mouthfeel.
• Individually wrapped to preserve texture and prevent sticking.

Is this cookie box suitable for gifting and special occasions?

Yes — the presentation, portion size, and shelf stability from individual wrapping make this 9-count box a convenient choice for birthdays, thank-yous, corporate gifts, and event favors. The iconic look of the black and white cookie reads as a thoughtful, recognizable sweet gift for recipients of many ages.

• Attractive boxed set of nine cookies ready to gift or send by mail.
• Individually wrapped for easy inclusion in gift baskets or party packs.
• Classic, familiar appearance that suits many occasions and recipients.
• Ships well without significant risk of smearing when handled properly.

What dietary and allergen information should buyers know?

Stern’s Bakery produces these cookies in a nut-free facility and lists kosher certification, offering reassurance for many shoppers. As with any baked good, customers should review the product label for complete ingredient and allergen details if they have specific sensitivities beyond nuts.

• OK & CRC kosher certified for observant customers.
• Baked in a nut-free facility to reduce cross-contamination risk with tree nuts and peanuts.
• Individually wrapped packaging helps prevent cross-contact during transit.
• Check the ingredient list on the box for gluten, dairy, or egg information if relevant.

How long will the cookies stay fresh and how should they be stored?

Individually wrapping each cookie extends freshness during shipping and short-term storage. For best texture, store the cookies at room temperature in a cool, dry place and consume within the timeframe printed on the box; refrigeration can dry the cake, while freezing preserves longer-term freshness.

• Room temperature storage recommended for short-term enjoyment.
• Refrigeration is not necessary and may firm the icing and dry the crumb.
• Freeze wrapped cookies to extend shelf life; thaw at room temperature before serving.
• Consume within the manufacturer’s best-by period stated on the packaging.

Who is this for? This nine-cookie box from Stern’s Bakery is aimed at anyone who loves nostalgic New York bakery classics, needs a dependable kosher and nut-free gift option, or wants individually wrapped cookies for events and mail-order gifting. It’s ideal for hosts, office celebrations, care packages, and fans of iconic, simple desserts who value bakery-fresh taste without complicated presentation.

Ingredients

Enriched Wheat Flour (Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid, Malted Barley Flour, Potassium Bromate), Sugar, Canola Oil, Palm Oil, Soybean Oil and Hydrogenated Cottonseed Oil, Eggs, Filtered Water, Invert Sugar, Cocoa (Processed with Alkali), Corn Syrup, Natural & Artificial Flavors, Baking Powder, Mono & Diglycerides, Salt, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Propionate (to preserve freshness).